--- title: "Nobody Surveyed the Spare Room, So We Interviewed the (Fictional) Sister Who Owns It" canonical: "https://anchor.is/docket/issue/55/lab/article/50662/nobody-surveyed-the-spare-room-so-we-interviewed" publication: "The Docket" publisher: "The Docket" language: "en-US" guide: "https://anchor.is/docket/llms.txt" issue: 55 section: "lab" section_name: "The Lab" published: 2026-10-22 word_count: 1881 source_links: 10 --- # Nobody Surveyed the Spare Room, So We Interviewed the (Fictional) Sister Who Owns It *October 22, 2026* [Read on the website]() *A note for the record. Billie Stenhouse took her own transcript of this conversation on the steno machine she used for 31 years in Los Angeles courtrooms. That is diligent of her, given that she does not exist. Billie, her sister Corinne, the bungalow, the dog named Exhibit B, and every word below were invented for The Lab. The surveys, statutes, deadlines, and figures she runs into are real, and they are footnoted. Billie asked us to add that being fictional is still a promotion. "Real hosts," she said, "aren't in the data at all."* --- The Eaton fire ignited on January 7, 2025. It destroyed more than 9,000 structures and killed 19 people.[^1] Eighteen months later, Los Angeles County's permit dashboard showed 100 homes rebuilt out of 6,746 units destroyed.[^2] The most detailed picture of where survivors are living comes from a survey of 2,023 people taken this June for the Department of Angels, a recovery group founded after the fires by the California Community Foundation and Snap Inc. By its count, two in three people who lived in Altadena when the fire hit are still displaced. Its definition of displaced includes anyone "living in a rental, hotel/motel, or with family and friends due to the fires." One answer a respondent can choose reads: "I'm staying with friends or family in a stable temporary arrangement because of the fires."[^3] Hold on to the word *stable*. Billie certainly has. That answer belongs to the guest. We found no published count of the households doing the hosting, and no survey that asks them anything. FEMA's one-time displacement payment can go toward staying with family or friends, but it goes to the displaced applicant, who may or may not pass any of it along.[^4] **On paper, the host is an address.** Billie's address is a 1920s bungalow in west Altadena, its eaves still yellowed by smoke. The sewing room stopped being a sewing room on January 9, 2025. That was the day her younger sister Corinne arrived with a laundry basket of whatever had been in her car. Corinne's house, eleven blocks east, is now a slab and a stack of permit binders. On the Thursday we visited, Corinne was out at the lot with a contractor. A whiteboard calendar on the fridge had one date circled in red. Exhibit B, a dog of uncertain breed and total confidence, slept under the table on a box labeled CORINNE / SALVAGE / DO NOT. Nobody had finished the label. Billie sat at the dining table behind her steno machine, the squat keyboard court reporters use to take down whole syllables in a single stroke. It clicked through everything, including the silences. --- ## The survey counts Corinne as displaced and counts your house as her housing. Has anyone asked you about that? **Billie:** No. *[She keys it in anyway. One stroke.]* ## Not the insurer? FEMA? A case manager? **Billie:** The adjuster asked me once if I was "the relative." I said, "I'm the sister." He wrote down *relative*. *[She laughs.]* I sat in courtrooms for thirty-one years. I know exactly what it means to be in the room and not on the record. If it isn't on the record, it didn't happen. > And I have not been happening in my own kitchen since January of last year. ## What does the arrangement actually ask of you, day to day? **Billie:** The money's the smallest part. Groceries, the water bill, fine. It's *this*. *[She pats the table.]* This was my dining table. It is now Corinne's recovery office. Insurance binder, permit binder, Edison binder, a binder for the binders. Somebody in *Forbes* called recovery "essentially a job,"[^5] and that's right, except the job's office is in my house, which makes me the office manager. I know her claim number better than my own Social Security number. I'd recite it for you, but I consider it privileged. My house has its own story, by the way. It stood. Smoke, ash, the eaves you saw on the way in. My claim was denied, which is apparently common. In that same survey, close to half the people with standing homes who aren't displaced have had claims denied.[^3] So my house doesn't count as damaged, and I don't count as displaced. I'm the place people are displaced *to*. ## Corinne's policy covers additional living expenses. Has she offered to pay you? **Billie:** Since month two. I've said no since month two. ## So why are we talking about it now? **Billie:** Her public adjuster. That's the adjuster you hire to argue with the adjuster they send you. Very tall young man, talks like a podcast. He told her some insurers will pay a relative a reasonable daily rate for putting you up. A claimant-side adjusters' blog says the insurer "should be willing,"[^6] and I have transcribed enough depositions to know *should* and *will* are different words. Whether her company does it under her policy, we don't know yet. I haven't seen anyone official say it's happening here. But ALE, that's additional living expenses, the part of a policy that pays for your hotel while your house is a slab, runs on receipts.[^7] So the plan goes like this. I write a lodging agreement. Every month I hand my sister a receipt. Maybe the insurer reimburses her, and she passes it to me. I've been chewing on that for weeks, because the money exists. It was built for exactly this. Twenty-six percent of survivors in that survey have already run out of temporary-housing coverage,[^3] and Corinne hasn't, partly because I'm free. Which means my generosity has been... subsidizing her insurance company? I did not expect to say that sentence out loud. Strike that. *[Beat.]* No, leave it in. But a receipt makes me a landlord. I'd have to pick a number. **What's my sister per night?** The hotel rate? The going rate? Rents around here went sideways after the county let its rent-gouging cap lapse in May.[^8] Am I supposed to price Corinne against *that*? And a lease has a term. That's the part that keeps me up. Right now nobody has said how long. Write it down and suddenly there's an end date, and somebody has to sign it. *[Pause.]* Or maybe that's the point. Maybe a receipt is the first piece of paper in twenty-one months that admits I'm part of this. I honestly can't tell whether it makes us sturdier or shakier. Ask me in January. ## January keeps coming up. **Billie:** *[She nods at the fridge, at the red circle around January 7.]* Twenty-four months. California law says ALE has to be available at least that long after a declared disaster, "subject to other policy provisions," which is lawyer for *unless*. A policyholder-side law firm calls the date "a milestone, not an automatic cutoff."[^9] So maybe it keeps going. Maybe she hits her dollar limit first. Every institution in her life comes with a date. FEMA had dates. Her case manager is gone at the end of the month; AP says about 1,400 households are losing theirs.[^10] I'm the only party with no date. People hear that and think *safety net*. Fine. > But a net with no date is also a net nobody inspects. ## So who decides when the arrangement ends? **Billie:** *[The steno keys go quiet.]* I thought you'd ask about money. *[Long pause. Exhibit B rearranges himself on the box.]* I assumed it ends when her house is done. Last I looked, the county had a hundred homes rebuilt out of 6,746 units destroyed.[^2] Hers is still in plan check, where the county reviews your drawings before anybody's allowed to pour a foundation. So "when the house is done" is somewhere out past the horizon. And honestly? I've been assuming she'll decide. She's been assuming I will. Neither of us has said it. We have been extremely polite. Stenhouses are polite right up until we aren't. ## Could you ask her to leave? **Billie:** Legally? Sure. Would I? Never. *[Beat.]* But I've noticed I stopped asking whether I *could*. That's a different thing from *wouldn't*, isn't it? I don't need her permission to have my book club over. I still check with her first. I couldn't tell you when that started, and I write down everything. ## If someone finally surveyed hosts, what should they ask? **Billie:** I've had twenty-one months to draft this. *[She tears a page off a legal pad. The handwriting is very small and very certain.]* - Did anyone ask you before it started, or did it just start? - Who decides when it ends, and has anyone said so out loud? - What did you stop doing to make room? - What would make you say no, and could you? - Who's paying, and do they know you exist? And one for the guest: "Do you know what your host gave up?" Corinne would say yes. She'd be about sixty percent right, which is a very good score for a sister. ## Last one. Is it stable? **Billie:** *[Laughs.]* "Stable temporary arrangement." That's the box the survey lets Corinne check. Jumbo shrimp. Military intelligence. It's stable because *I'm* stable. If I break a hip, if my roof goes, if my insurer drops me, Corinne's "housing" moves. The moratorium that kept insurers from dropping people up here ran out last January.[^1] The survey will record that she moved. It won't record why. *[The front door opens. Corinne, holding a binder. Exhibit B abandons the box to greet her, which Billie notes, for the record.]* There she is. Ask her if it's stable. She'll say yes. She'll be right. Today. --- *When we left, Billie printed her transcript. Under APPEARANCES, where a court reporter lists everyone present, she had typed her own name first.* [^1]: Pasadena Now, "Bill to Extend Insurance Moratorium for Eaton Fire Survivors Clears Assembly Committee," April 16, 2026. This is the source for the fire's toll and for the lapse of California's one-year nonrenewal moratorium in early January 2026. We have not confirmed the bill's final status. https://pasadenanow.com/main/bill-to-extend-insurance-moratorium-for-eaton-fire-survivors-clears-assembly-committee [^2]: LAMag, "Only 1% of Eaton Fire Homes Rebuilt After 18 Months," citing the LA County permit dashboard. https://lamag.com/environment/wildfires/only-1-of-eaton-fire-homes-rebuilt-so-far-two-thirds-of-survivors-still-displaced/ [^3]: Department of Angels / Embold Research, *Community Voices: LA Fire Recovery Report, July 2026.* The survey drew on 2,023 adults recruited through social media ads and voter-file texts, weighted, and conducted June 3–15, 2026. It was commissioned by a philanthropy-founded recovery group. People without stable phones or housing may be underrepresented. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6792c245599ed84703227b1e/t/6a60ec825c62c877b0a8e4be/1784736898126/Department+of+Angels+Survey+Memo_July+2026.pdf [^4]: FEMA, "Displacement Assistance." https://www.fema.gov/press-release/20250507/displacement-assistance [^5]: Monica Sanders, "What It Takes To Come Home," *Forbes*, October 13, 2026. https://www.forbes.com/sites/monicasanders/2026/10/13/what-it-takes-to-come-home-altadenas-complicated-road--to-recovery/ [^6]: Miller Public Adjusters, a claimant-side firm. We found no regulator or insurer statement confirming relative-hosting reimbursement for Eaton claims. Practice varies by policy and insurer. https://www.millerpublicadjusters.com/free-property-insurance-claim-advice-blog/insurance-and-additional-living-expenses [^7]: Insurance.com, "Additional living expenses coverage: A complete guide." https://www.insurance.com/home-and-renters-insurance/natural-disasters/additional-living-expenses.html [^8]: LAist, "LA County to end ban on rent gouging…," May 2026. https://laist.com/news/housing-homelessness/los-angeles-county-price-rent-gouging-fires-expiration-may-2026 [^9]: Property Insurance Coverage Law blog, written by a policyholder-side law firm, on California Insurance Code §2060. Readers should check the statute and their own policy terms. https://www.propertyinsurancecoveragelaw.com/blog/california-wildfire-ale-extensions/ [^10]: Associated Press via Dar News, "LA fire survivors are set to lose case managers as standoff between California and FEMA drags on," October 2026. https://www.darnews.com/world/la-fire-survivors-are-set-to-lose-case-managers-as-standoff-between-california-and-fema-drags-on-afcfdfd4 ## More - [The Lab — Issue 55]() - [Issue 55]() - [Publication guide]()