---
title: "Three Sittings With Opal Crabbe and the Apple That Stopped Being Sour"
canonical: "https://anchor.is/docket/issue/58/futures/article/65778/three-sittings-with-opal-crabbe-and-the-apple"
publication: "The Docket"
publisher: "The Docket"
language: "en-US"
guide: "https://anchor.is/docket/llms.txt"
issue: 58
section: "futures"
section_name: "Future Tense"
published: 2026-11-13
updated: 2026-11-14
word_count: 1689
source_links: 11
---

# Three Sittings With Opal Crabbe and the Apple That Stopped Being Sour

*November 13, 2026*

[Read on the website](<https://anchor.is/docket/issue/58/futures/article/65778/three-sittings-with-opal-crabbe-and-the-apple>)

*Regional Oral History Collection, Yakima Valley Series. Accession YV-0417. Crabbe, Opal (b. 1979). Three sessions, 2031, 2049, 2068. Catalog status: speculative. The narrator is invented. She has asked that the record note the trees are not. The collection has declined to rule on the matter.*

---

The Crabbe place is four and a half acres outside Zillah, at the tail end of an irrigation ditch. In a valley that rations water by seniority, that is the worst seat in the house. Behind the house stand seven apple trees that Agnes Crabbe planted in 1947 on seedling roots, the kind of tree that can go fifty years or more[^1]. With luck and stubbornness one can reach a century, though nobody promises fruit at that age[^2]. Six of the trees are ordinary. The seventh leans over the ditch bank and bears a small, homely green apple that the family has called a "Sour" for four generations.

The collection started visiting Opal around the time the valley began forecasting its water monthly, the way other places forecast rain. In September 2026 the basin entered its fourth straight drought year. Snowpack sat under half of normal even though precipitation ran above average, and junior users, the farms whose water rights came latest and get cut first, were told to expect 60 percent of their entitlement[^3].

Most oral histories catch a person once, late, looking back across a life[^4]. We wanted to see what moves when the same narrator gets the same questions at long intervals. So we asked them, and we wrote down whatever moved. Her answers are grouped by question rather than by year. Three interviewers asked them. She outlasted two.

---

## Tell me about the tree by the ditch.

*2031. The porch, 6:10 a.m. She scheduled it early. By ten the boards are too hot for bare feet.*

**Opal:** That's a Northern Spy. Grandma Agnes got the whip, that's a baby tree, one stick, off a man in Moxee for two dollars and a pie, and she was never once wrong about an apple. Small, green, ugly. Sour enough to make your ears ring. The other six are just trees. That one's family.

*2049. The kitchen table. A shade sail hangs over the porch now, and she still won't sit under it. She peels a Sour in one unbroken strip while she talks.*

**Opal:** Well, it's not a Spy. My granddaughter sent leaves to the lab in Pullman. They ran it against everything with a name, and it came back nothing. *Unidentified.*[^5] So it's… I don't know what it is. Something a bird planted, maybe. Agnes said Spy because the Moxee man said Spy, and I said Spy because Agnes did. Forty years I corrected people. *(laughs)* I corrected a man from the Extension once. I'd like that one back.

*2068. A recliner, turned toward the window that faces the ditch.*

**Opal:** It's the Sour.

## Does the tree have enemies?

*2031.*

**Opal:** Mike Pruitt. Three hundred acres of Honeycrisp across the road, and he thinks my seven trees are a codling moth hotel. That's the worm in your apple, if you're not from here. He reported me to the county board.[^6] They sent a very nice letter and a pamphlet about their removal program. Free! They'll come cut down your grandmother for free. I used the pamphlet to level the dryer.

*2049.*

**Opal:** The Pruitts pulled their block in '43. It's mostly solar panels now, and cheatgrass where it isn't. I outlasted them. You'd think somebody would give you a ribbon. *(pause)* When they quit, I bought two years of their water. So that's whose water kept her alive. I try not to do that math.

*2068.*

**Opal:** I forgave Mike Pruitt in 2052. He'd been dead six years. It went fine.

## What did the bad years ask of you?

*2049 only. On the recording this answer runs forty minutes. It has been abridged with her permission and over her objection.*

**Opal:** The year the ditch went dry in July. '38? '39. Thirty-nine. I had a fellow out from WSU, young, very kind, and he says, "Mrs. Crabbe, you have to decide whether you're keeping the crop or keeping the tree." As if those were two different things. Turns out they are.

So we cut her back by half. More than half. Teo did the cutting, and I stood at the foot of the ladder telling him he was killing her, which was a big help to everybody. Then you paint the big limbs with white latex so they don't sunburn once the leaves are gone,[^7] and there she stands looking like a fence post that went to a wedding. No apples for two years. Not one.

June, that's my granddaughter, wanted scionwood. Those are the cuttings you graft from. She came down in February and we cut pencil twigs off the last year's growth, and she wrapped them in a wet paper towel inside a bread bag in my crisper, and they molded. Too wet. You want them damp, not drowned.[^8] The next winter we did it again, and that time they took. Now she's got four grafts going up in Everson, by the Canadian border, where it rains like it means it. I asked her why she couldn't just plant seeds, and she looked at me like I was simple. "A seed gives you a stranger, Grandma."[^9] You want the Sour, you need a piece of the Sour.

I told her that was fine. I didn't…

You want the honest thing? I didn't want the Sour somewhere else. I wanted it here. The biology people say a graft is the same apple, and I believe them. The tree is another matter. The tree is the one Agnes stood under. The twig is more of a photocopy. *(pause)* I know that's not fair to the twig.

## Does it taste the way it did?

*2031.*

**Opal:** Why wouldn't it?

*2049.*

**Opal:** Sweeter. Softer. Goes mealy by October, and half the time we're picking in August anyway. People like it better. The church ladies like it better. That's the insult.

*2068.*

> **Opal:** They're not sour anymore.[^10] We still call them Sours. *(long pause)* June mailed me one from Everson last fall. Little green thing, ugly as ever. I ate it standing at the mailbox. It was sour. *(pause)* Two hundred miles north.

## Who kept these trees alive?

*2031.*

**Opal:** Me. Agnes before me. Crabbes.

*2049. Same answer, nearly word for word. Omitted.*

*2068.*

**Opal:** You people have asked me that twice now, and twice I said me. *(pause)* Teo Ruelas. Teodoro. Twenty-six summers he was up that ladder. On the hot days I'd tell him to go sit in the truck and take a break, engine off, on account of gas, you know. I thought that was shade. A parked truck in August is an oven with a radio in it.[^11] Nobody told me until he'd retired and I read it somewhere. I called him up to apologize, and he said, "Señora, I knew." He'd been sitting under the Sour the whole time. *(laughs, then stops)* He knew that tree better than I did. Put that in.

## What happens to the tree after you?

*2031.*

**Opal:** She'll outlive me. Apples on old roots go a hundred years. She's barely eighty-four.

*2049.*

**Opal:** My son says take her out and sell the water. He says it like it's arithmetic. Well, it is arithmetic. *(pause)* I used to say she'd outlive me. Now I say it's a race, and I don't know who I'm pulling for.

*2068.*

**Opal:** No apples in four years. The leaves still come. I pay for the water. I have the girl from the co-op come out and prune. Every spring the board sends its letter, and I send back the form saying yes, I'm controlling pests. Which is true. There's nothing on that tree a moth would want.

## Then why keep watering it?

*2068. Asked once.*

> **Opal:** *(a long time)* You're the third one of you to sit in that chair. The first one never asked me that. She just wrote down that I was sure.

*She asks that the recorder be left running and goes out the back door toward the ditch. The tape runs eleven more minutes. Most of it is the hose.*

---

**Archivist's notes**

[^1]: University of Missouri Extension notes that apples on nondwarfing rootstocks can live 50 years or more. https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/mg6

[^2]: At Hopewell Furnace, the National Park Service tends Civilian Conservation Corps trees nearly a century old. In September 2026 it canceled public picking because almost no fruit remained, and it kept caring for the trees anyway. https://www.nps.gov/hofu/learn/historyculture/apple-orchard.htm

[^3]: Bureau of Reclamation, Yakima basin water supply forecast, September 3, 2026. https://www.usbr.gov/newsroom/news-release/5405

[^4]: For example, Mary Ann Borina Radovich's 1977 oral history, in which she recalls Watsonville apple growing from the 1930s on. https://library.ucsc.edu/reg-hist/radovich

[^5]: There is precedent. At Aspet in New Hampshire, one century-old tree remained unidentified after DNA testing, and the park propagated it regardless. Another tree there carried three different names before testing settled on one. https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/saint-gaudens-aspet-apple-trees.htm

[^6]: Well before 2031, backyard growers in Yakima County were required to control pests that could spread to commercial orchards. WSU guidance listed removal programs as the alternative. https://extension.wsu.edu/benton-franklin/agriculture/pests/bentonfranklincohortpestdiseaseboards/

[^7]: WSU's *Drought Advisory: Tree Fruits* (revised 2001) described heavy canopy reduction that improved survival odds while severely cutting production. It also recommended painting exposed scaffold branches against sunburn. https://wpcdn.web.wsu.edu/wp-ecommerce/uploads/sites/2/product-3531-sku-EM4820.pdf

[^8]: Cooperative Extension grafting guidance calls for dormant shoots from the previous season, labeled and refrigerated, and warns that too much moisture molds scionwood. https://apples.extension.org/apple-tree-propagation-grafting/

[^9]: Iowa State Extension: apple seedlings do not reproduce the parent fruit's taste, size, or color. https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-apples-home-garden

[^10]: Sugiura et al. (2013) analyzed 30 to 40 years of records for Fuji and Tsugaru apples in Japan and found declining acidity and firmness associated with warming. The study did not include Sours. https://www.nature.com/articles/srep02418

[^11]: As of 2026, Washington Department of Labor & Industries heat rules did not count a sun-heated parked car as shade unless it was running with air conditioning. https://www.lni.wa.gov/safety-health/safety-training-materials/workshops-events/beheatsmart

## More

- [Future Tense — Issue 58](<https://anchor.is/docket/issue/58/futures/markdown>)
- [Issue 58](<https://anchor.is/docket/issue/58/markdown>)
- [Publication guide](<https://anchor.is/docket/llms.txt>)