Arlis Thirdshare does not appear in the 1935 Census of Agriculture. He is also missing from every county abstract, church ledger and lease book in Greer County, Oklahoma. We made him up, along with his wife, his mule, his landlord and the handshake lease he holds on wheat-and-cotton ground north of Mangum. He took the news better than most tenants take news. "Only renter in the county with a guaranteed term," he says. "Long as you keep reading."
Everything around him is real.
A shelterbelt is a long band of trees planted to break the wind, and in the mid-1930s the federal government set out to plant a great many of them down the middle of the country. The project's first tree went into the ground on the H. E. Curtis farm near Mangum on March 18, 1935, and the town became a district office.1 In January 1936 the Associated Press announced that planting would begin "immediately" at Mangum, Elk City and Chillicothe, Texas, with 158 miles of belts planned for Oklahoma. Planned is the operative word. The AP was reporting a target, and said so.2 That spring the government quit leasing planting sites and started asking individual farmers to cooperate.3
Cooperating meant a good deal more than nodding. The planners' technical proposal sketched a typical strip about 132 feet wide, which comes to sixteen acres for every mile.4 Cooperators gave up the land, supplied the fencing materials, prepared the ground, cultivated the young trees and fought the rodents. Crews from the Works Progress Administration, the New Deal's big jobs program, built the fences and did the planting.1 The agreements were signed with landowners.5 And in 1935, 61.2 percent of Oklahoma's farms were run by tenants.6
So who, exactly, was being asked?
We went looking for a real tenant's account of this conversation and came back empty-handed. Surviving project files are comparatively thin for Oklahoma.7 Arlis is assembled from the records surrounding that silence. His rent, his landlord and his doubts are invented. The numbers he's chewing on are not.
We find him in November 1936, sitting on the beam of a walking cultivator (a mule-drawn rig for weeding between crop rows) at the north edge of the field. A line of survey stakes runs east from there, rags tied to their tops and snapping in a wind that always seems to have an appointment somewhere else with the topsoil. The forestry man's card is in his shirt pocket. His lease comes up at New Year's.
What did the forestry man actually ask you for?
Arlis: A strip. His word. Said it the way you'd ask somebody to pass the bacon. [He grins.] Hundred and thirty-some feet wide, clean across the north end, which is the best wheat ground I've got. That Mrs. Sprague's got. Hear that? Two years on a place and "my" creeps in like bindweed.
He had a drawing, too. Cottonwood, Chinese elm, green ash, Osage orange, red cedar, all lined up nice. Pretty drawing. Trees are always full-grown on paper. Same as the hog on the feed-store calendar.
Whose name goes on that paper?
Arlis: Hers. She owns it. He was square about that, I'll give him that much. Came out here first, walked the line with me, asked what I thought. Then he drove to town to see her. I watched his dust all the way to the section road. Some of it was mine.
Did what you thought count?
Arlis: About like weather counts. You notice it and you plan around it. [He stops.] No. That's not fair to him. He'd rather have the tenant willing. Somebody has to run a cultivator through those rows, and it won't be Mrs. Sprague and it won't be a man in a necktie.
Could I say no? Nobody's told me I could. Nobody's told me I couldn't. Out here that means you find out by trying, and then you find out where you're living next year.
Walk me through the arithmetic.
Arlis: I'm on thirds and fourths. She takes a third of the grain and a fourth of the cotton. I furnish the team, the tools, the feed and the back.8 Pull that strip out of wheat and she loses a third of nothing. I lose two-thirds of nothing, and I still owe the work. They don't teach that kind of figuring at the schoolhouse. The teacher'd quit.
Does the rent change? I asked him. He said that's between me and her. So I asked her. She said, "We'll see." [He laughs.] In this county, "we'll see" is a whole contract. It's got clauses.
And don't write me down as poor. Tenant is a word for temporary. Poor is a word for certain years, and this one hasn't made up its mind.
Has anyone offered to pay you for the ground?
Arlis: No. [He waits, in case the question has a second half.] No.
Relief crews on the project draw $27 to $45 a month for 130 hours, according to the AP. Ever think about signing on?2
Arlis: That's real money. So say I went on relief, which I'd sooner not. I could draw wages planting trees on ground I quit drawing a crop off. Then, once the crew drove away, I'd cultivate those same trees for free. The government's got a sense of humor. Nobody's had the heart to tell it.
The trees run on one clock and your lease runs on another. How do you hold both?
For the record: planners expected the fast growers to reach four to six feet in three years and to start working as a windbreak after five.4 The 1935 census counted 54,531 Oklahoma tenants who had been on their farm less than a year, and 27,836 who had stayed five years or more.9
Arlis: [A long exhale.] Badly. At night, mostly, which is the wrong time to hold anything heavier than a quilt.
Here's how the paper lays it out. First year, four passes through those rows. Second year, three. Then two. Then one.4 It's a countdown. Like the tree's learning to ride a bicycle and I'm running behind holding the seat. After that, the fella said, there's still the outside strips and the fence, and clearing tumbleweeds out of the wire. He said "tumbleweeds" like it was nothing. Tumbleweeds are never nothing. Only crop in Greer County that harvests itself and then comes back for your fence.
Now my side of it. A handshake lease that comes up at New Year's, and has twice. Your census says fifty-some thousand tenants had just unloaded the wagon. Half that many had stayed five years. I know those aren't predictions. Nobody counted who was leaving next. But set that number beside four-three-two-one and you see the trouble. That's ten trips down those rows before it's half a windbreak. I'll do the four. I'd probably do the three. The two and the one, somebody else does those, or nobody does.
Here's the part I can't make come out even.
I want the trees. I've watched this wind lift the topsoil off this place and deliver it to Texas without a stamp. I'd like to see something stand up to it. But I can't tell whether I'm planting trees or planting myself.
A man who's tending four passes of saplings, maybe she keeps him on. Maybe that's my lease, growing in a row. Or maybe she sells to somebody who wants the trees and not the man who raised them. [He taps the card in his pocket.] I keep thinking I'm the one being asked. I've about decided I'm not. They're asking whoever's standing here in 1941.
Want to hear something about the people doing the asking?
In June 1936, congressional conferees settled on $170,000 to raise and distribute the seedlings already growing while the larger project wound down. Time magazine ran the story under the headline "Orphan Seedlings."10
Arlis: [He squints east, down the stakes.] Orphan seedlings. So the government's on a one-year lease too.
It gets better. Or worse. Can I tell you about next spring?
The project is surviving on WPA emergency money, with no act of Congress behind it. In May 1937, Agriculture Secretary Henry Wallace will tell President Roosevelt that this is a serious handicap. The project will also get a new name, the Prairie States Forestry Project.11
Arlis: Prairie States Forestry Project. [He tries it out twice, like a man testing a board before he puts his weight on it.] Sounds like it's got a pension. Well. Me and the government understand each other, then.
Both of us asking somebody else to put down roots we can't promise to stay for.
A 1938 Forest Service leaflet will claim that under the "most favorable circumstances," some fast growers shot up ten feet in a year and twenty-four in three. Does that cheer you?12
Arlis: Most favorable circumstances. I've farmed since I could reach the plow handles and never once met them. I'd like to shake their hand. I'd like to know where they're renting.
Can I tell you what happens later?
Arlis: Is it bad?
It's complicated. Do you want it anyway?
Arlis: I've had worse out of the mailbox.
In 1975, federal investigators found farmers pulling out windbreaks to plant more ground or make room for irrigation. One Oklahoma farmer told them that tearing out a mile-long belt gave him back about sixteen acres. Roughly half was where the trees had stood. The other half was the ground beside them, where crops wouldn't grow.13
Arlis: [He's quiet a while.] Sixteen acres a mile.
The same number they're asking of you.
Arlis: Same sixteen. Forty years on, somebody buys them back from the trees. [A short laugh.] Can't say he was wrong. He's the one farming beside them. Trees drink, and they shade, and none of that made it onto the pretty drawing. That ground next to the trees is the part nobody's counting yet. Me included, till about a minute ago.
There's a scorecard, too.
The 1975 investigators didn't yet consider removals a serious problem in the sixteen counties they examined, though they worried about the losses adding up. In Nebraska, aerial photos from 2016 showed 40 percent of the old belts fully intact, 36 percent partly intact and 24 percent gone.7
Arlis: So three out of four are still standing, one way or another. [He considers it.] That's better odds than a tenant gets.
So what will you tell her?
Arlis: [He takes out the card, turns it over and puts it back.] I'll tell her I'll run the four passes. After that, I don't know. Maybe I'm the one standing here in 1941, looking at a windbreak. Maybe it's some fella I'll never meet, cussing tumbleweeds out of my fence. [A pause.] My fence. There I go again.
Footnotes
-
Bruce Hoagland, "Shelterbelts," Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture, Oklahoma Historical Society. https://www.okhistory.org/publications/enc/entry?entry=SH022 ↩ ↩2
-
Associated Press dispatch, Pampa Daily News, January 26, 1936. Figures are announced plans. https://collections2.swco.ttu.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.12255/161116/Pampa_Daily_News_1936_01_26.pdf?isAllowed=y&sequence=1 ↩ ↩2
-
USDA, Department of Agriculture, War Food Administration, and Constituent Agencies, printed p. 20. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b6/Department_of_Agriculture%2C_War_Food_Administration%2C_and_constituent_agencies_%28IA_CAT11085435004%29.pdf ↩
-
D. S. Olson and J. H. Stoeckeler, "The Proposed Tree Plantations—Their Establishment and Management," in USDA Forest Service, Possibilities of Shelterbelt Planting in the Plains Region (1935). These are planning specifications. https://npshistory.com/publications/usfs/shelterbelt/sec4.htm ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Tianshu Li, "Protecting the Breadbasket with Trees? The Effect of the Great Plains Shelterbelt Project on Agriculture," Land Economics 97(2), 2021. https://doi.org/10.3368/le.97.2.321 ↩
-
Sixteenth Census of the United States: 1940, Agriculture, Oklahoma, County Table II (comparative 1935 figures). https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/decennial/1940/agriculture/1940-census-agriculture-vol-1-oklahoma.pdf ↩
-
Sarah Karle and Richard Carman, "Digital Cultural Heritage and Rural Landscapes," Built Heritage, 2020. Nebraska data only. https://doi.org/10.1186/s43238-020-00006-6 ↩ ↩2
-
Oklahoma Historical Society, "Tenant Farming and Sharecropping." https://www.okhistory.org/publications/enc/entry?entry=TE009 ↩
-
U.S. Census of Agriculture, 1935, Oklahoma County Table IV. These are retrospective occupancy categories, not forecasts. https://www.nass.usda.gov/AgCensus/archive/files/1935-Oklahoma-COUNTY_TABLES-1516-Table-04.pdf ↩
-
"Conservation: Orphan Seedlings," Time, June 8, 1936. https://time.com/archive/6755464/conservation-orphan-seedlings/ ↩
-
Edgar B. Nixon, ed., Franklin D. Roosevelt and Conservation, 1911–1945, vol. 2, Part III, including Wallace to Roosevelt, May 18, 1937. https://npshistory.com/publications/fdr/part3.htm ↩
-
USDA Forest Service, Tree Planting on the Prairie States Forestry Project (1938). Promotional claims, attributed. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/Tree_planting_on_the_prairie_states_forestry_project_%28IA_CAT10679751%29.pdf ↩
-
U.S. General Accounting Office, Action Needed to Discourage Removal of Trees That Shelter Cropland in the Great Plains, RED-75-375 (1975). https://www.gao.gov/assets/red-75-375.pdf ↩
