Nobody will let me near the people who pump out the New York subway system.
Not the MTA press office. Not the union. Not the workers themselves, who've learned that talking to reporters is a good way to get in trouble.
I've been trying for three weeks. Started after riding the 1 train in early November and noticing water stains on the tunnel walls—fresh enough they hadn't turned that permanent subway black yet. High water marks from the July storms. Two separate deluges that summer knocked out stations across Manhattan. The viral videos showed waterfalls pouring down subway stairs, passengers standing on seats as brown water filled the cars. By the next morning, service was restored. The MTA chairman praised "hundreds of people" who "worked overnight" to pump out the system.
Hundreds of people. No names. No details about what that night was like.
I wanted to know what happens in those pump rooms when the water comes. What decisions get made in real time when your infrastructure is designed for 1.75 inches of rain per hour and you're getting double that? What the work actually looks like when the engineering specifications meet a flooded tunnel at 2 a.m.
The MTA press office sent fact sheets about $700 million allocated for climate resilience. Elevating vents, expanding pump capacity. Eight billion already spent since Sandy. They offered an engineer who could explain technical challenges.
I said I wanted to talk to pump room operators. The people who were down there overnight on July 14 and 31.
"We'll check on that," the press officer said.
That was two weeks ago.
I tried Transport Workers Local 100. Left messages. Sent emails explaining I was writing about infrastructure labor and climate adaptation. Got a callback from someone who said the union was focused on safety issues right now—the Federal Transit Administration audit that found a 58% increase in near-miss events, overtime concerns, important stuff. But when I asked specifically about pump room operations during storms, the conversation went vague.
"It's specialized work. The MTA has procedures."
So I started hanging around stations. 28th Street on the West Side, which got hammered in July. 191st Street in Washington Heights. Watched maintenance workers come and go, tried to strike up conversations. Got friendly nods, nothing about the work. One guy told me he'd been with the MTA for 23 years. I asked what he did during the July storms.
"We handled it," he said, and walked away.
Last week I went to a community board meeting in the Bronx where MTA officials were presenting climate adaptation plans for local stations. Residents asked good questions about flooding, about whether the improvements would actually work. The MTA reps showed slides with engineering diagrams and budget allocations. Smooth presentation, practiced answers, the kind of thing they probably do twice a week.
During Q&A, I asked if any of the maintenance workers who operate the pump rooms were present. Could we hear from them about what they're dealing with?
The room went quiet in a way that told me I'd violated protocol. The MTA official—a middle-aged guy in a blazer who'd been smooth through the whole presentation—paused just long enough to make it awkward.
"Those workers are busy keeping the system running," he said.
His tone was pleasant. His meaning was clear: that's not how this works.
A few people shifted in their seats. Someone coughed. The official moved to the next question about station elevator repairs.
After the meeting, I caught up with one of the residents, a woman who'd lived in the neighborhood for 40 years and commutes on the 4 train every day. She'd asked sharp questions about whether the flood barriers would actually hold. I told her what I was trying to do.
"They're not going to let you," she said. She wasn't being unkind about it. Just stating fact. "You know that, right? The MTA doesn't want people hearing that the workers think the system's overwhelmed. The union doesn't want workers saying anything that could get them in trouble. And the workers themselves—they just want to do their jobs and go home."
She looked at me like I was naive for not understanding this already.
"You see those water stains in the tunnels? That's what climate change looks like here. Not in the capital plans. In the tunnels. And the people who deal with it every day aren't allowed to tell you about it."
Then she left to catch her train.
What it means that the MTA spends eight billion on resiliency but won't let anyone talk to the people who actually implement it. What kind of climate adaptation requires making the adapters invisible. These are the questions I keep coming back to.
The 300 pump rooms scattered through the subway system handle 13 million gallons of water on an ordinary day. Some of the pumps date to 1914. The system was designed for average rainstorms. We're not getting average rainstorms anymore. Over the last 20 years, there have been 34 torrential rain events that impacted MTA service, with intensifying flooding in recent years.
All of this from press releases and news coverage. None of it from the people who operate the pumps.
Those workers have developed informal knowledge about which pumps to prioritize, how to coordinate during storm events, what works when the official procedures aren't enough. They've figured out how to keep trains running through conditions the system wasn't designed for. All of that expertise is invisible. Deliberately so.
I'm still trying. I've got more calls out, more emails sent. Maybe eventually someone will talk to me about what it's actually like down there when the water keeps coming. What they see that the planners miss. What gets said in those pump rooms that never makes it into the engineering reports.
But three weeks in, here's what I can tell you: the water keeps coming, the pumps keep running, the workers keep showing up.
And we keep not hearing from them.
Climate adaptation in New York is happening. It's just happening in a way designed to stay invisible, performed by people we've decided don't get to speak.
-
Hurricane Ida's scale: During the 2021 storm, the MTA pumped 75 million gallons of water out of the subway system —five times the normal daily volume and a glimpse of what "overwhelming the system" actually looks like.
-
Mott Haven Yard flooding: Metro-North's main Manhattan hub experienced 20 separate flooding events between summer 2016 and summer 2024, showing how chronic climate impacts compound in critical infrastructure locations.
-
Overtime cap removal: In 2019, NYC Transit Authority's acting president lifted the overtime cap that had been put in place so workers "wouldn't be worked to death", revealing the tension between system demands and worker protection during climate emergencies.
-
Flood mitigation spending: The MTA has installed 3,500 flood mitigation devices including flex gates, flood logs, and marine doors at a cost of $350 million, though the July flooding showed these barriers aren't enough when rainfall exceeds design capacity.