In the spring of 1935, the federal government shipped roughly two hundred families from the upper Midwest's Cutover Region to Alaska's Matanuska Valley. They came from Michigan, Minnesota, and Wisconsin, where they had been farming land the timber companies had logged down to stumps, then watching low prices, drought, and the relief rolls finish the job.1 The offer was generous and conditional in about equal parts. It included paid transportation, up to 2,000 pounds of freight per family, equipment and groceries on account, and a projected thirty-year mortgage at three percent. Planners figured on about $3,500 per family. They figured low, by a wide margin.2
Thirteen years later, a government geographer counted 63 of the 201 original families still in the valley and pronounced the colony "effective and generally successful."3 Both facts hold, and this conversation takes place in the gap between them. Anyone who has heard a flooded neighborhood described as "back" while its original residents rent two towns over may recognize the arithmetic.
Hulda Ledgerquist kept her household's books in northern Minnesota and then in the colony, and she left Alaska in 1936. She is also made up. We built her to fit the outline the archives leave empty, which, she points out, is still more paperwork than most departing wives got. The policy details are footnoted. Her family is invention, and she'll tell you where one ends and the other begins. We met at a kitchen table that exists only in this paragraph. She brought the ledger. She would like it on the record that it balances.
You brought a ledger. What's on page one?
Hulda: Freight. Two thousand pounds per family.2 You would not believe what that number does to a marriage. The cream separator came. My mother's sideboard stayed in Aitkin County. You find out what a family weighs, and then you find out who gets to do the weighing.
Page two is the account. Household goods were charged before we ever left Minnesota, and once we landed, supplies went on account too. People back home said the government gave us everything. It did. It just had a pencil behind its ear.
The program wanted families "mainly of Scandinavian ancestry," with farming experience and physical strength.1 Did you feel chosen?
Hulda: Chosen, and weighed, same as the freight. They picked Arvid for his back. They picked me for being married to it.
(She smiles, then puts the smile away.)
We were farming stumps. The lumber companies took the pine, sold what was left to people like us, and called it farmland. Then prices fell. Then it quit raining. So when Alaska came along, it sounded like a second try on somebody else's dime. Or somebody else's loan. I kept mixing those two up. Everybody did.
By February 1936, the colony's own newspaper was calling one departing family's explanation a "lame excuse."4 What was it like to leave with the whole valley watching?
Hulda: Oh, the Pioneer. They'd line up the quitters next to the fellows waiting to take over the empty farms, debts and all, so readers could compare. A good editor can make a train ticket look like a character flaw.
Everybody wanted your reason in one word. The office kept its own list: illness, dissatisfaction with management, unsuited to farming, asked to leave.2 Very tidy. I never met anybody who left for one word.
So what were yours?
Hulda: Here's where I quit being footnoted and start being made up. Mind the seam.
Einar, our youngest, picked up a cough in the tent camp that wouldn't settle. Arvid fought with management about the house. Everyone fought with management about the houses. It was the valley's main sport. And I sat up nights with this book, watching the account grow faster than anything we'd planted.
Wanting to go never moved anybody an inch, though. People forget that part. Leaving costs money. The 1935 planning papers expected colonists to pay their own way back after the first year.5 We left at about thirteen months. I still couldn't tell you which side of that line we landed on, or who got to decide. And the debt didn't evaporate. That May, officials held a meeting about taking promissory notes from departing colonists for what they owed, and admitted they hadn't much way to collect.5 So.
(She taps the ledger.)
I signed a promise to pay for a farm I was walking away from. Nobody forgave anything. They just let the debt ride the train with us. It weighed nothing. It weighed more than the separator.
There's a photograph at the Wisconsin Historical Society of families at Matanuska waiting for the Seward train.6 I'm not in it. I'm not in anything. That's the one perk of being invented. Nobody can misidentify me.
Did Arvid want to leave?
Hulda: He came.
That's all?
Hulda: That's all the file would ever know. The papers say "the family," as if a family sits down at supper and votes. Somebody decides, somebody goes along, and then a clerk writes down "the family." The Pioneer's school notes once mentioned, in a single line, that a pupil named Ronald Emberg had recently left for the States.7 A boy's whole year in one sentence. I'd like to know whether anybody asked him.
In April 1936, the Pioneer ran an editorial titled "One of Our Pet Peeves." It argued the houses and fields would stay occupied and productive even if the current residents left, because "it doesn't make much difference who."8
Hulda: (A long laugh.) Pet peeves. We'd been promoted to somebody's pet peeve.
What galls me is that he was right. By 1944, Interior was reporting cleared land, Army markets (the war had brought a great many hungry soldiers to Alaska), and loans being repaid. The same report mentions tracts abandoned by original purchasers, or taken back from them, being sold to new settlers.9 Pay it off and you got a real deed. So the farm got its happy ending. It just got it with another name on the mailbox.
The town and the household are two different patients. One can make a full recovery while the other moves to Duluth.
That geographer counted 63 of 201 original families still in the valley in 1948, which is 31 percent, and called it "generally successful."3 Does that put you in the failure column?
Hulda: His yardstick was settling the Territory permanently. Nobody promised him we'd all stay on our own tracts. Either way, a family in Duluth falls off both measures.
Minnesota sent sixty-six families, and twenty-five were still there. And the university archive says two hundred and three founding families, not two hundred and one.10 So two families have gone missing from somebody's arithmetic, and nobody's sent a search party. Give me the books and I'd have them found by lunch.
Failure? We rented rooms upstairs. Arvid took whatever work there was. I missed the June light something terrible. Einar's cough got better, or he outgrew it, and I'll never know which. I won't call it freedom, and I won't let the Pioneer call it a lame excuse. We moved. Some things got better. Some things stayed in the valley.
The newspaper was called the Pioneer. But the valley wasn't empty.
Hulda: No, it wasn't. The 1880 census counted seven Dena'ina villages there, and Dena'ina people were growing vegetables before we showed up with our seed catalogs.1 The Native Village of Eklutna, a Dena'ina community, says its people moved seasonally across that country and governed themselves long before anyone from outside got around to recognizing it.11 Even the Park Service concedes it can't say exactly what homesteading did to them. It names disease, and the loss of hunting and fishing grounds.1
I won't invent a meeting so I come out looking good. The honest answer is that I didn't know what I was looking at. We were told it was a beginning. For them it was somewhere in the middle of a much longer story. They're still there. Their history doesn't run through our thirty-one percent.
So what did "success" miss?
Hulda: Mostly whatever happened after the train. The paperwork stops at the platform.
There are files in Anchorage: checkout papers, quitclaims (the forms you sign to give up any claim on the land), debt settlements, letters about sick colonists being sent home. Most of them aren't digitized.10 Somewhere there may be a folder that knows more about a family like mine than I do. Which is saying something, considering I'm made up.
(She closes the ledger.)
A place can succeed and a family can leave it. Both go in the same book. You just need two columns, and somebody willing to keep both.
Footnotes
-
National Park Service, Alaska's Matanuska Colony: Teaching with Historic Places. https://www.nps.gov/common/uploads/teachers/lessonplans/Matanuska%20Colony%20Teaching%20with%20Historic%20Places%20lesson%20plan%20materials1.pdf ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Fran Seager-Boss and Lawrence E. Roberts, The Settlement and Economic Development of Alaska's Matanuska-Susitna Valley, National Register filing, 1990. https://npgallery.nps.gov/NRHP/GetAsset/NRHP/64500003_text ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Kirk H. Stone, Alaskan Group Settlement: The Matanuska Valley Colony, Bureau of Land Management, 1950, Table 8 and chapter 11. https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/gdc/gdclccn/91/16/46/11/91164611/91164611.pdf ↩ ↩2
-
Matanuska Valley Pioneer, February 6, 1936, p. 2, Palmer Museum. https://palmermuseum.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/80_Matanuska_Valley_Pioneer_2_6_1936.pdf ↩
-
Robert Redder Franklin, "Matanuska? Mister, She's Tough": New Deal Agricultural Settlement in Alaska, 1933–1940, Washington State University MA thesis, 2014. https://rex.libraries.wsu.edu/esploro/outputs/graduate/Matanuska-Mister-shes-tough-New-Deal/99900525067001842 ↩ ↩2
-
Wisconsin Historical Society, Arville Schaleben, "Families Leaving from Colony," 1935. https://www.wisconsinhistory.org/record/image/W01461X/families-leaving-from-colony ↩
-
Matanuska Valley Pioneer, April 30, 1936, p. 4, "School Notes." https://palmermuseum.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/94_Matanuska_Valley_Pioneer_4_30_1936.pdf ↩
-
Matanuska Valley Pioneer, April 16, 1936, p. 3, "One of Our Pet Peeves." https://palmermuseum.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/91_Matanuska_Valley_Pioneer_4_16_1936.pdf ↩
-
Department of the Interior, Annual Report, 1944, "Alaska Rural Rehabilitation Corporation." https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GOVPUB-I-f8722cb04bc221deb9c9e4378e232fa4/html/GOVPUB-I-f8722cb04bc221deb9c9e4378e232fa4.htm ↩
-
UAA/APU Consortium Library, Alaska Rural Rehabilitation Corporation records, HMC-1174. https://archives.consortiumlibrary.org/collections/specialcollections/hmc-1174/ ↩ ↩2
-
Native Village of Eklutna, "About Native Village of Eklutna." https://eklutna-nsn.gov/about/ ↩
