On September 8, 1864, the Sacramento Bee ran a few lines about a house on I Street, between Second and Third. Workmen were jacking the wooden building into the air, part of the city's long effort to lift itself above its rivers, when it "took a lurch and spilt out all the occupants." The occupants were Chinese residents, the paper said, and none of them were hurt. A carpenter named Bryan was badly bruised. The owner, J. Lehman, was named.
The people who tumbled out were not. Nothing in the item says whether they paid Lehman rent, whether anyone warned them before the jacks went under the floor, or where they slept while the house stood propped on its supports.
Those few lines matter because of where they sit. In the 1860s Sacramento decided to raise its business district out of reach of the floods, and it required every owner along the affected streets to take part. Few acts of collective flood adaptation in early California are better documented. Nearly all of that documentation follows property: who owned a lot, how many feet of it faced the street, what the work cost, who bought the lot when a bill went unpaid. The people who lived and worked in buildings they didn't own appear mostly when something went wrong.
Merchants who didn't wait
The floods of the winter of 1861–62 put Sacramento underwater. In March 1862 the city's property owners met to decide what to do, and some of them didn't wait for a plan. They began raising the street and sidewalk in front of their own buildings.
The first response, then, came from people who had just watched water fill their stores. They moved fast, and they moved alone, which created its own trouble. Historian Barbara Lagomarsino records an episode, repeated in the city's historic-district filing, in which R. H. McDonald raised his sidewalks ten feet above their old level. The Board of Supervisors, which governed the city then, asked him to bring them down to three feet, and he did. The record gives no exact date, only that it happened after merchants started acting on their own.
McDonald had every reason to fear the river. But a sidewalk ten feet up protects one storefront. The shop next door ends up facing a wall, and anyone walking by faces a drop. A street keeps water out only if it runs unbroken across every lot. Someone had to set a single height for an entire block, which engineers call the grade, and then get every owner on that block to build to it, including owners who couldn't pay, owners who didn't want to, and owners who lived somewhere else.
A three-man board and a contractor's bill
In 1863 the state legislature gave Sacramento a new charter, the founding document that lays out how a city is run. Its second section, as the U.S. Supreme Court later quoted it, was brief:
"The city of Sacramento shall be governed by a board of trustees consisting of three members."
Those three trustees now controlled the streets. Most of what we know about how they used that power comes from historians piecing it together from the charter and the trustees' records. The city built retaining walls, called bulkheads, along the edges of a street and filled the space between them with dirt up to the new grade. Owners were expected to handle the stretch in front of their own lots. In Lagomarsino's account, as the city filing summarizes it, "If an owner refused to do their part … the trustees hired a contractor to do the work then charged the owner accordingly." She puts the contractor's price at three dollars a foot of bulkhead. The trustees chose which blocks would be raised, and owners' objections counted only if two-thirds of them objected.
Court records show how the money moved. Street costs were billed to owners as "assessments," divided by how many feet of each lot faced the street, as an 1875 case describes. According to the California Supreme Court in Mayo v. Ah Loy, the charter said these bills would be collected the way the state collected unpaid taxes. An unpaid bill went delinquent, a lawsuit followed, and then the sheriff sold the lot.
That sequence turned raising from a choice into an obligation. Before the charter, an owner raised his frontage if he could afford it and wanted to. Under it, the duty came attached to the land. An owner who did nothing still got a wall at the curb and a bill for it, and if the bill sat long enough, the lot could be sold to cover it.
For owners, what came next was expensive and physical. John Frederick Morse, Lagomarsino notes, had an offer to raise his 40-by-50-foot building at Second and K for $1,200. In October 1866 the Bee described the Odd Fellows Hall at K and Third "standing several days on about 150 jack screws," the heavy screw-driven lifts used to raise buildings inch by inch. Owners who couldn't or didn't lift their buildings sometimes added a story on top and let the old ground floor become a basement. The paperwork the city filed to register Old Sacramento as a historic district describes first-story doors and windows that still sit below today's street.
Because owners raised their frontage when they had the money, the city went up unevenly. The registration paperwork describes sidewalks at different heights joined by stairs, ladders and ramps. Anyone hauling goods down the block, or just walking to work, climbed up and down past the owners who had paid that season and the ones who hadn't yet.
The raising also left a gap at the edge of every block. The roadway between the curb walls was packed with dirt up to the new grade. In many places, the strip behind each curb wall, running back to the old building fronts, was not. A new sidewalk was laid across that strip at street height, like a deck, with open space underneath reaching down to the old ground level, where some original ground-floor doors and windows survive below the street. Those are Sacramento's hollow sidewalks, and they are still there.
The bill that went to the wrong name
The trustees' power was real, and the courts put limits on it.
In 1864 part of Lot Three, between Second and Third and I and J streets, was billed for grading I Street from Front to Sixth. The bill was entered under the name "F. LeRoy." The owner was Theodore LeRoy. Nobody paid. The city sued to collect, but LeRoy was never formally notified of the suit in the way the law required, and the suit was never properly brought against the lot itself. He never appeared, the court ruled against him by default, and in June 1865 the sheriff sold the property to Eli Mayo.
When Mayo went to take possession, people were living there. Ah Loy and others occupied the premises, so they were the ones Mayo had to take to court to get through the door. LeRoy, the owner the bill had misnamed, joined the case, and so did a man named Lehman, who also claimed an interest in the property. In 1867 the state Supreme Court ruled against Mayo. Without proper notice, the court that ordered the sale had never had the power to order it, so the sale had no legal force.
This is the same stretch of I Street where the Bee's house tipped over in 1864, and the name Lehman turns up in both. The records don't say whether they describe the same building or the same man. They do show how occupants entered the paperwork. Ah Loy and the others are there because they stood between a sheriff's buyer and a front door. The terms of their stay, and what happened to them after the ruling, weren't written down.
The 1875 case came out of an 1869 owners' petition to grade and plank Tenth Street. The bill that followed skipped some property that benefited from the work. The legislature passed a law declaring the uneven bill valid anyway, and the Supreme Court threw out both the bill and the legislature's fix.
So the system had protections: proper notice, and a share of the cost that matched your neighbors'. They went to the people who held title, because owners were who the system was built to reach.
Tenants at the edge of the record
One tenant does surface by name in the newspapers, a woman identified only as Mrs. Dunn. On May 3, 1865, the Sacramento Daily Union reported that Sam Brannan had bought the old Vernon House, raised it and added a basement. "By raising the building its capacity has been greatly enlarged," the paper said. Renamed the Brannan House, it had rooms for boarders, a dining room and shared parlors. Mrs. Dunn had rented it and was furnishing it.
She appears as the woman who will run the improved building. The article doesn't mention her rent, whether it carried some of Brannan's raising costs, or what the work meant for whoever had lived there before. The residents of Lehman's house appear as bodies inside an accident, and Ah Loy as an obstacle to a buyer.
Beyond those glimpses, very little survives. The county assessor's records, held at the Center for Sacramento History, list owners, values, improvements and taxes, not who lived or worked inside. The registration filings, histories, newspapers and property records reviewed for this piece don't establish what share of downtown buildings were rented, what raising cost tenants in moved stock, lost trade or nights spent elsewhere, or whether landlords folded street assessments into rent. Boarders and shopkeepers lived through every season of the raising, and almost none of their account was kept.
The tool that made the raising enforceable explains much of that. It was a lien, a legal claim on the land that could force a sale if the bill went unpaid. A lien attaches to whoever holds the deed. It records nothing about who sleeps in the building.
The hollow sidewalks and Miami Beach
Some of what the 1863 charter attached to those lots is still attached.
On March 24, 2026, Sacramento's city council adopted a resolution describing its Hollow Sidewalk Monitoring Program. The city inspects the spaces under the sidewalks and notifies owners, and the resolution states that owners are responsible for repairs. The city's sidewalk guidance warns that owners may be liable for injuries from broken sidewalks. The same day, the council created a Hollow Sidewalk Repair Project and moved $1.2 million from its gas tax fund to pay for engineering and construction at selected locations. The general duty still belongs to owners, and the resolution now sends public money to specific sites.
Miami Beach has spent the past decade raising streets against flooding from high tides, and it is working out its own version of the arrangement. In November 2016, Joey Flechas of the Miami Herald reported on Sunset Harbour businesses left below newly raised roads. Antonio Gallo's restaurant, Sardinia, ran into trouble with a flood claim when the adjuster classified it as a basement, which limits what flood insurance pays. City officials disputed that and said they were working with the adjuster and FEMA, the federal agency that runs the national flood insurance program. "It doesn't make sense that we're a basement just because the city raised the road," Gallo said. The article doesn't say how the dispute ended. Sacramento's sunken ground floors went through what he described: the street rose and the room stayed where it was.
For its West Avenue Phase II project, Miami Beach has spelled out what happens where a raised road meets private property, a step it calls "harmonization." Owners get a plan for their parcel and an agreement granting the city access, and the city covers that transition work in the project budget. If an owner hasn't agreed by the deadline, the design shifts so construction stays inside the public right of way, the strip the city controls. That can mean retaining walls, railings or raised sidewalks, which the city acknowledges may make getting in and out harder. The city's project page has listed October 26, 2026, as the anticipated start of road raising and harmonization on the segments under construction, and spring 2027 for their completion, dates it says are subject to change.
Set beside the 1863 charter, the two approaches run in opposite directions. Sacramento built the wall if you refused and sent you the bill. Miami Beach pays to connect the street to your door if you sign, and builds its wall at your property line if you don't. Both cities faced McDonald's problem, a street that has to rise as one piece across many owners, and both answered it by putting a decision in front of each person holding a deed.
The city's public description of West Avenue is addressed to those owners. A family or business renting a ground floor while the road outside climbs isn't the party being asked to sign. In Sacramento in 1864, people in that position reached the record through a few lines in the Bee, after the house had already tipped.

