An Airstream sits in Verna Batim's driveway in Kerrville, Texas, an orange extension cord trailing to it from the garage. She bought it in March. The plan was Big Bend, then Santa Fe, then anywhere a freelance court reporter with a hotspot could take down a deposition. Since July it has traveled about forty feet. It is her office now, because her old office is her mother's bedroom.
Dot Batim, 81, lived in a small house near the Guadalupe River until this summer's flood made it unlivable. Within a week, a family group chat had reached a decision, and Dot moved into Verna's downstairs room "for now." Verna has two brothers, one in Houston and one in Denver. She is the one with the room.
Families across the Hill Country have been living inside decisions like that all fall. On October 21, the San Antonio Express-News reported that FEMA had denied Individual Assistance, the program that pays households directly for needs like rent and repairs, to Kerr and Uvalde counties. The paper quoted a Kerrville woman whose displaced parents were among eight people sharing a 1,200-square-foot house, because the apartments the family had looked at were out of reach.1 On October 30, Texas announced that its appeal had been approved.2 An application window opened. The guest rooms stayed full.
They tend to. A sociologist who followed families after Hurricane Ida in Louisiana found adult children still hosting displaced relatives months after the storm. One daughter estimated she had spent 40 hours on her parents' insurance alone.3
A note on Verna. She is invented, assembled from that kind of reporting, and she exists only on this page. Say her name fast and you get her job description. She says being imaginary is roughly how visible she has felt since July. We talked in the Airstream. Through the aluminum you could hear Wheel of Fortune.
The family texts all say "we decided." Who was actually in the room?
Verna: Nobody was in a room. Write that down first. It was a group text called "Dot Com." My brother Dale named it in 2014 and still considers it his finest work. Mom's at the church shelter, and Kurt, who does logistics for an oil company, God help us, sends this. I can quote it exactly, because quoting is literally the job: "Obviously Mom stays with Verna short term while we figure out the house."
Obviously.
Dale hearts it. Mom gets on the phone and announces she is not going to "one of those apartments," like apartments are catching. And I typed "ok for now."
So that's the "we." Kurt moved, Dale seconded with a heart, Mom vetoed every alternative, and I supplied the room. For about two weeks I honestly thought that was fair. I'm the one who's here. I work from home, allegedly.
Then at 2 a.m. one night I found a study about daughters who mostly have brothers getting treated as the obvious caregiver. The reasons stack up: she's close to Mom, she's patient, she's "good with that stuff."4 Every one of those was true about me. That's the trap. Nobody had to be sexist. They just had to be accurate.
What nobody typed was anything after "for now." In a deposition, when a witness says "for now," a good attorney circles back to it. In my family, nobody circles back.
What did giving up the room cost?
Verna: Start with the work. Remote depositions need a door that shuts. First week, Mom wanders in behind me during a malpractice depo, in her housecoat. Opposing counsel says, very gently, "Is everything all right, Ms. Batim?" And I said, "Let the record reflect my mother."
So now I work in the trailer I bought so I could leave.
I know how that sounds. It's a nice trailer, and I'm aware nobody's organizing a benefit concert for me. But the house was paid off, my son's grown, and I was going to rent the place out in January and go. I'd just never said it out loud in a way that counted. So when the "we" convened, my plan wasn't on the agenda. Nobody knew I had an agenda.
People keep mentioning family leave. Does it help?
Verna: Everybody forwarded me FMLA stuff. The Family and Medical Leave Act gives you twelve weeks, job-protected, but only if you're an eligible employee of a covered employer, and it's unpaid either way.5 I'm freelance. My leave policy is that I don't get paid. I've turned down eleven jobs since July. I counted. Counting is my other occupational disease.
Kurt Venmos me four hundred a month with the memo "Mom stuff" and a little house emoji, and I'm grateful. I really am. AARP, which lobbies on this, so grain of salt, just estimated that caregivers spend about $11,500 a year out of pocket, and the biggest share goes to household and housing costs, more than medical.6 That tracks. Her pills are a whole other article. Money, at least, I can count. Being on duty at breakfast doesn't go in Venmo.
The federal appeal was approved last week. Did that make anything easier?
Verna: It gave me a fresh thing to hate. Of course I read the FEMA guide. I read everything; it's a sickness. The lodging reimbursement doesn't cover staying with family, which I expected. But for rental assistance, one of the conditions is that she doesn't have access to adequate rent-free housing.7
So I'm sitting there going, am I that? Is my guest room "adequate"? Because if it is, I might be the reason she can't get the help that would let her live somewhere else. I genuinely don't know. The guide doesn't say a daughter's house automatically counts, and I'm still waiting to talk to an actual human. I'm not going to guess on the record. I know what happens to guesses on the record.
That's when the "we" picked up a fifth member. The federal government is in the group chat now, and it also thinks I said yes.
Are you being fair to your brothers?
Verna: (A long exhale.) Kurt's house took water too. Not like Mom's, but he's got three kids and a mess. Dale's wife has her own mother up in Pueblo. Dale calls Mom every single night, which I don't, because I've seen her all day. They're doing what they can from where they are.
But "from where they are" only works if somebody's standing in the place. I'm the place.
There's an old British study about a daughter-in-law who hosted her mother-in-law for eight months after a flood. Her sisters-in-law had flooded houses too, and she resented them anyway.8 I read that and thought, oh. Both of those get to be true.
In a national survey, 65 percent of live-in caregivers said they had no choice, and about half of all caregivers said it gives them purpose.9 Which group are you in?
Verna: Both.
Both?
Verna: She taught me to drive on Highway 27. She does the crossword in pen, which tells you most of what you need to know. Some nights she yells the Wheel answer before a single letter's up, and she's right, and I think, this is the year I got. Then at 7:40 the next morning I'm in a trailer swearing in a witness, and I think, this is the year I lost. I don't get to strike either one from the record.
What happens next, with her house and with you?
Verna: Kurt has a spreadsheet with three tabs: Rebuild, Sell, and "Mom stays with Verna." The third tab has no cost column. I asked him to add one. He said, "What would we even put?" I said, put me.
(She looks at the house for a while.)
I have one son, in Lubbock. Nobody is texting him "obviously." I'm writing that down while I can still type.
The National Institute on Aging has a worksheet of questions to ask before you move a parent in. How do the other people in the house feel? What care is the host willing and able to give? What are the alternatives?10 Great questions. It says "before" right at the top. Nobody's asking those in a church fellowship hall in July.
A friend calls tomorrow. Her mother's house just flooded, and her brothers are already typing "obviously." What do you tell her?
Verna: This is just me talking. I'm not a professional anything except typing fast. Say yes if you want to say yes. But say "until" instead of "for now." Put a date in the chat, even a made-up one: "Let's look at this again at Thanksgiving." Make somebody build the cost column. And then...
(The bonus-round music starts up inside the house. She stops to listen.)
Sorry. She's going to get it. She always gets it.
Thanksgiving is three weeks out. Both brothers are coming. Verna has put it in the chat.
Footnotes
-
Liz Teitz and Ricardo Delgado, San Antonio Express-News, October 21, 2026. "FEMA denies assistance request for July flood victims in Kerr, Uvalde counties." https://www.expressnews.com/hill-country/article/kerr-county-flood-kerrville-fema-aid-22487139.php ↩
-
Texas Division of Emergency Management, October 30, 2026. "Additional federal disaster assistance following July storms and flooding." https://tdem.texas.gov/press-release/10-30-26 ↩
-
Brandon Folse, "Eroding Landscapes, Emerging Carescapes," Socius, August 30, 2024. Qualitative study of 30 participants, all with pseudonyms. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/23780231241275362 ↩
-
"How Do Own and Siblings' Genders Shape Caregivers' Risk of Perceiving Care-Related Criticism From Siblings?" Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 2023. https://academic.oup.com/psychsocgerontology/article/78/3/520/6873895 ↩
-
US Department of Labor, FMLA Frequently Asked Questions. https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fmla/faq ↩
-
Laura Mehegan and Chuck Rainville, AARP Research, "2026 Caregiving Out-of-Pocket Costs Study," October 28, 2026. Survey-based estimates; AARP is a caregiving-policy advocate. https://www.aarp.org/pri/topics/ltss/family-caregiving/family-caregivers-cost-survey-2026/ ↩
-
FEMA, Individual Assistance Program and Policy Guide, version 1.1, amended July 2025, printed pp. 79–82. https://www.fema.gov/sites/default/files/documents/fema_iappg-1.1_amended_july2025.pdf ↩
-
Rebecca Sims, Will Medd, Maggie Mort and Clare Twigger-Ross, "When a 'Home' Becomes a 'House': Care and Caring in the Flood Recovery Process," Space and Culture, 2009, pp. 310–312. https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/fass/wp/cuidar-hub/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/When-a-Home-Becomes-a-house-Care-and-Caring-in-the-Flood-Recovery-Process.pdf ↩
-
National Alliance for Caregiving/AARP, Family Caregivers of Adults Age 50-plus: The Caregiving in the US 2025 Series, July 2026. Figures are self-reported perceptions. https://www.caregivingintheus.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/family-caregivers-of-adults-age-50-plus-caregiving-in-us-2025-series.doi_.10.26419-2fppi.00412.001.pdf ↩
-
National Institute on Aging, "Questions To Consider Before Moving an Older Adult Into Your Home." https://www.nia.nih.gov/sites/default/files/2023-04/worksheet-questions-moving-older-adult-into-your-home.pdf ↩
