When the power failed at Blackberry Oaks, a senior apartment complex for low-income residents in Groveland, California, the first thing Barbara North heard was the alarm on her oxygen machine. Some nights it woke her in the dark.
"When my electricity goes off, I'm in a mess," she said.
She could walk through the mess step by step. A backup battery, given to her for free, sat in her bedroom, but it couldn't run her oxygen machine. When the alarm went off, she switched to compressed-oxygen tanks. Each one lasted about eight hours, she said. "When that runs out, you're really — excuse my expression — screwed."
During the outages, her neighbor Deborah Karr came over to play gin rummy.
North was in her 80s, living with lung disease and congestive heart failure, when she described those nights to reporters Emma Foehringer Merchant and Maria Parazo Rose. She talked to them from a leather easy chair in an apartment furnished with doilies. Their investigation, "Lights Out," was published by Type Investigations and High Country News a year ago this week. Everything in the public record about how she handled outages comes from that one conversation.
Nobody arranged Karr's visits, and no program counts them. The programs that exist for people in North's position address the other parts of her routine: the warning, the battery and the power line itself.
Outages that come without warning
Groveland is a small town in Tuolumne County, in the Sierra foothills on the road to Yosemite. Its electricity comes from Pacific Gas and Electric, the utility serving much of Northern and Central California. PG&E's power lines can start wildfires when something goes wrong on them, a branch brushing a wire, for instance. To lower that risk in fire-prone areas, the company has set protective devices on its lines to cut power the moment they sense a problem. PG&E calls these Enhanced Powerline Safety Settings. Almost everyone else calls them "fast trips."
Many Californians know the other kind of fire-season outage, the planned Public Safety Power Shutoff, which PG&E schedules ahead of forecast windstorms and announces days in advance. With a planned shutoff, a household has time to charge equipment, call family or drive to a relative's house. A fast trip comes with no notice. State regulators acknowledge that customers can't be warned, because the power cuts out at the same moment the problem happens.
The lines serving North's building tripped 19 times across 2023 and 2024.
PG&E does have a program for people like her. Its Medical Baseline program, open to oxygen users whose need is certified by a doctor or other medical provider, offers a discounted rate on the extra electricity medical devices use, along with extra warnings before planned shutoffs. Those warnings don't reach a fast trip. On the nights North described, the first notice she got was her own alarm.
Earlier settings, longer waits
Across PG&E's territory, fast trips jumped in 2024. The utility logged 2,379 of them in 2022, 2,263 in 2023 and 2,820 in 2024, according to a May 2025 report from the independent monitor state regulators assigned to watch PG&E's safety work. The monitor gave two reasons for the rise. PG&E turned on its most sensitive fire-season settings earlier in the year, and it changed the model it uses to estimate fire danger.
Both were decisions the utility made about risk. The report counts outages; it doesn't measure how long fire season ran in the foothills, or how long the line feeding Blackberry Oaks stayed at its most sensitive setting. But each added week with lines set to cut out at the first fault is another week when an alarm like North's could go off.
The same report measures outage length two ways, and in 2024 the two measures went in opposite directions. The time the average affected customer spent without power fell from 193 minutes to 150, about two and a half hours. The time until every affected customer had power back rose from 367 minutes to 410, close to seven hours. Both can be true at once, because crews can get most homes back quickly while the last ones keep waiting.
| PG&E outage measure | 2023 | 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Time the average affected customer spent without power | 193 minutes | 150 minutes |
| Time until every affected customer had power back | 367 minutes | 410 minutes |
Set those numbers beside an eight-hour oxygen tank. An average outage fits inside one tank with room left over. Waiting to be the last home reconnected uses up most of it. These are averages across a territory that covers most of Northern and Central California, not measurements taken at Blackberry Oaks, and they tell you nothing about the worst night of any given season. Still, for someone like North, whose breathing depends on how long the outage lasts, the second number is the one to watch. Inside her apartment, what counted was how many tanks she had, how full they were, and who would bring more when they ran low.
The battery that couldn't run the machine
PG&E built a program for exactly this problem. Its Portable Battery Program serves customers who depend on medical equipment, are enrolled in Medical Baseline or otherwise identified as vulnerable, and have been through at least three fast-trip outages since 2024. Partner organizations assess how much power each person needs and try to match a battery to it. People who need more than a portable battery can provide are supposed to be referred to another program, Disability Disaster Access and Resources, whose transportation and hotel help is described for planned shutoffs, the announced kind North wasn't dealing with.
North had a battery in her bedroom, but it couldn't run her machine, and the tanks made up the difference. The published account doesn't say where her free battery came from, or whether anyone measured what her machine needed before it showed up.
PG&E's program page now says the battery program is full and that applications for 2026 are closed.
Buried lines on a preliminary schedule
The utility's long-term answer to fast trips is burying power lines, where they can't spark fires the same way. PG&E aims to have more than 1,900 miles buried in its highest-risk areas by the end of 2027. Its county maps show planned work in Tuolumne County for 2026 and possible work for 2027. The company calls these plans preliminary, subject to permits, access, weather and shifting risk priorities. They make no commitment about the particular wire that runs to Blackberry Oaks.
Until that wire changes, the plan for a household like hers is the one North described: tanks, and a neighbor at the door. Anyone caring for someone on home oxygen in fire country, in the Sierra foothills or along Colorado's Front Range, can work through the same questions her routine answered. Will the power give any warning before it goes? How long do the longest outages last, compared with the typical one? How many hours of backup are actually in the room? And who will come to the door, and how fast?
A year ago in Groveland, the answer to that last question was Deborah Karr, who came over with the cards and kept North company while the tanks ran down.

